For my MFA in Dramaturgy, I chose to
create a website that contains three annotated early printings of
Shakespeare’s
Hamlet. These
printings are known as the First and Second Quarto, and the First
Folio. My goal was to make a site useful in both high school and
college classrooms and as a research tool for performance, working on
the principal that understanding context can create confidence. The
comparison of three original texts of
Hamlet
demonstrates that there is no such a thing as a “definitive” Hamlet
because, as these texts show,
Hamlet
is not a singular story. There are, in fact, three substantially
different stories we refer to as Shakespeare’s
Hamlet, each with their own unique
origins and distinctive characteristics. The website contains each of
these three texts and allows theater practitioners, students and
scholars to explore each of Shakespeare’s texts singularly and in
comparison.
Each text is available as an autonomous
text, but the texts may also be compared and read side-by-side. For
greater detail in while comparing, I have also created a line-by-line
comparison option.
In creating this project, I have essentially done the job of a
dramaturge without a specific production to tailor my research to—I
included materials useful in both the study and the performance of
Hamlet, from production history to historical context. My research
comes from a desire to ensure that the site is true to the idea of the
play(s) in performance, as opposed to on the page, and this is the main
thrust of the project. As a dramaturge with a specialization in
Shakespeare and Renaissance English literature, I not only want to do
justice to Hamlet’s illustrious stage history, but also to provide a
sense of the play in its original historic and social context, which
aids both performance and research. For example, Anne of Denmark was
Queen of England when the first two texts were printed, and this may be
why no line claiming that Denmark is a “prison” appears in these plays.
Readers may well detect a personal bias in my research and annotation
decisions, as I did have an agenda and a goal at the outset: to paint a
picture of the play in its original context and in
performance.
Notes and other resource material appear as
highlighted links in the
text and, when you select them, appear in the right hand pane of the
page. Images within the text range from production photos from
the
American Shakespeare Center’s recent productions of Hamlet in 2005 and
of Q1 in 2007, to classical paintings and sculpture.
Sound files will both give a sense of performance, and provide
opportunities to demonstrate rhetoric, meter, and experiments in
Original Pronunciation (an attempt to approximate the way English was
spoken in Shakespeare’s day). Many production history notes, from
costuming to staging, give readers a broad concept of the
many times and ways this story has been presented, but without showing
a particular bias on my part. If there is one thing I have learned
about these plays and this project, it is that people feel drawn to it
for a variety of
ways, and desire to stage it for as many reasons. I would encourage
everyone who comes to the play(s) to feel uninhibited in their
exploration of and thinking about these texts.
Editing
Notes
Each of the annotated scripts on the site are faithful
transcriptions from original copies of each printing. I have, however,
added line numbers and spacing in an attempt to make the texts more
reader-friendly. In the line-by-line comparisons, I have reset
extra-lineal words to their original line for the sake of comparison.
For example:
Ghost Yea he, that
incestuous wretch, wonne to
his will
O
wicked will,
and gifts! that haue the
power (with
gifts,
Becomes:
Ghost Yea he, that
incestuous wretch, wonne to
his will with
gifts,
O
wicked will,
and gifts! that haue the
power
Also in the line-by-line comparisons, I have placed stage directions in
single cells regardless of length and in some cases have slightly
changed the length of individual lines of text for spacing concerns.
Navigation
From anywhere in the site it is possible to navigate to any of the
three texts, from which you can access the comparison pages. Each
text has a color
scheme assigned to it to help provide a visual distinction: the First
Quarto is red, the Second Quarto is green, and the Folio is blue. If
readers find the color distracting or confusing, each may be converted
into a gray scale display.
The texts are available only in transcriptions of the
original spelling currently, but modernized spelling options are next
on my to-do list. The navigation bar at the bottom of the page is where
you will find the gray scale options, and links to the Homepage and
Comparison pages.
Navigation through the texts is available act by act, scene
by scene, and page by page.
List
of
Productions Mentioned in the Notes
(excerpted/compiled from Robert Hapgood’s Hamlet volume of the
Shakespeare in Production series).
Unless noted, names given are the name of the actor playing Hamlet.
Years given are the span of time over which the actor played Hamlet,
but do not necessarily indicate a continuous run. Names of other
actors, directors, etc. that are mentioned in the notes are listed as
well.
**Indicates a performance of the Q1 text
1600/1-1618: Richard Burbadge
1661-1709: Thomas Betterton, with Barton Booth as the Ghost.
1742-76: David Garrick
1777- 1784: John Henderson
1783-1817: John Philip Kemble
1803: Charles Kemble
1814-1832: Edmund Kean
1820-1833?: Junius Brutus (J.B.) Booth
1823-1851: William Charles Macready
1837: Pavel Mochalov
1838-1850: Charles Kean
1860-1891: Edwin Booth, with Helena Modjeska as Ophelia in 1891
1861-1870: Charles Fetcher, with Kate Terry as Ophelia in 1864.
1874-1885: Henry Irving, with Ellen Terry as Ophelia in 1878.
1875- Thomassano Salvini
**1881- William Poel
1884- Wilson Barrett
1886: Jean Mounet Sully
1889-90: Helena Modjeska as Ophelia, with Otis Skinner as Hamlet
1892: Herbert Beerbohm-Tree
1897: Johnston Forbes-Robertson
1899: Sarah Bernhardt
**1900- Dir. William Poel
1904: Julia Marlowe as Ophelia, with E.H. Sothern as Hamlet
1905: John Martin-Harvey
1912: Dir., Konstantin Stanislavsky/ Gordon Craig
1922-1925: John Barrymore
1926- Dir. Georges Pitoeff
1930-1944: John Gielgud, dir. Harcourt Williams (1930)
1933-5: Wilson Knight
1937: Laurence Olivier
1938: Alec Guiness; dir. Tyrone Guthrie
1948: Laurence Olivier (film); Peter Cushing as Osric
**1948- Benthall
1948-55: Paul Scofield
1949-58: Michael Redgrave
1951: Alec Guiness
1953: Richard Burton
1963: Peter O’Toole; dir., Laurence Olivier
1963- George Gizzard; dir. Tyrone Guthrie with Jessica Tandy as Gertrude
1964: Richard Burton; dir. John Gielgud
1964- Dir. Grigori Kozintsev
1965- David Warner; dir. Peter Hall with Glenda Jackson as Ophelia
1966: Tom Stoppard writes Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead
1969: Nicol Williamson
1970: dir., Trevor Nunn
1971-3: Ian McKellen
1975: Albert Finney; dir. Peter Hall
1975- Ben Kingsley; dir. Buzz Goodbody, with Charles Dance as
Fortinbras
**1978- Q1 production in Prague
1980: Tony Church as Polonius; Carol Royle as Ophelia
1980: Derek Jacobi, with Claire Bloom as Gertrude; Lalla Ward as
Ophelia, and Patrick Stewart as Claudius (BBC-TV)
1980: Jonathan Pryce, with Harriet Walter as Ophelia
**1983: Nottingham Playhouse
1990: (televised) Kevin Kline
1988: Mark Rylance, with Clare Higgins as Gertrude
1988-1992/3: Kenneth Branagh, in 1992/3 with John Shrapnel as Claudius,
Jane Lapotaire as Gertrude, Joanne Pearce as Ophelia.
1989: Daniel Day Lewis, with Judi Dench as Gertrude and Stella Gonet as
Ophelia
1990- Mel Gibson; dir. Franco Zeffirelli
**1992- Michael Muller (dir.) Shakespeare in the Park, Fort Worth, TX
**1992- Medieval Players (tour)
1994: Stephen Dillane, dir. Peter Hall, with Michael Pennington as
Claudius.
1995: Ralph Fiennes, with Francesca Annis as Gertrude
1996 Kenneth Branagh film with CAST
1997- Royal Shakespeare Company, Alex Jennings
**1999-2000- Red Shift production
2002: Peter Brook (film)
**2003- Theatre of NOTE; Alina Phelan as Hamlet
2005: Khris Lewin; American Shakespeare Center (Staunton, VA); with
Rene Thornton, Jr., James Keegan, Tracy Hostmyer, Sarah Fallon, John
Harrell, John Paul Scheidler, Eric Shoen, Matthew Sincell, Amy-Kristina
Herbert, James Beneduce, Bernard Bygott
**2007: Ben Curns; American Shakespeare Center (Staunton, VA), with
James Keegan, Vanessa Morosco, Susan Heyward, Christoper Seiler, Miriam
Donald, Andrew Gorell, Gregory Jon Phelps, Rene Thornton, Jr., Brett
Sullivan Santry, Rick Blunt
2007: Anna Northam; dir. Jaq Bessell, with Francis Boyle, Anna JL
Christiansen, Chelsea Collier, Katherine Mayberry, Lesley Larsen
Nesbit, Eve Speer, and Corey Vincent